Tenth Circuit Reverses Order and Closes Out Fifth Year of NCAA Eligibility
The Tenth Circuit revoked the fifth year of eligibility for 2022 athletes in the NCAA. Roughly 200 state cases and 850 athletes remain: what comes next for NIL.
The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit on Friday, November 6, 2026, reversed the nationwide injunction that allowed athletes from the 2022 class to play a fifth year in the NCAA, finding that the plaintiffs failed to define their labor market in the case Wisne v. NCAA, according to the AP.
The NCAA expanded eligibility to five seasons in June 2026, but only for incoming classes. A federal court in Colorado granted the extra season in July to those who graduated from high school in 2022, and the association appealed; the Tenth Circuit had paused the order in August. The three-judge panel, with Carolyn B. McHugh writing the opinion, held that the athletes did not define the relevant labor market, the first step of the antitrust analysis, according to ESPN. The July order threw rosters into disarray: players entered and exited rosters as state rulings shifted, such as Texas Tech quarterback Thomas Castellanos. For agencies and recruiting offices that connect U.S. programs with Mexican and Latin American athletes, the ruling narrows a window that served to retain talent.
McHugh wrote that a football player seeking a spot in Division I does not see the 101 schools without a football program as reasonable substitutes, and rejected the idea that all of Division I is a single market. The ruling does not resolve whether eligibility rules violate antitrust law, nor does it create a circuit split: the Third, Fourth, Sixth, Ninth and now the Tenth Circuits have reviewed similar claims without ruling against the NCAA, Sportico reported. Scott Bearby, the NCAA's general counsel, said the decision is "consistent with the approach taken by every federal court of appeals". The plaintiffs can seek en banc review by the full circuit or petition the Supreme Court, remedies that rarely succeed. Roughly 200 state cases involving up to 850 athletes remain.
For agents, NIL collectives and universities that work with athletes from Mexico and Latin America, the data leaves two fronts: federal eligibility no longer sustains the fifth year, and state litigation keeps moving rosters. The operational question is how many name, image and likeness deals depend on an extra season that is not guaranteed today.
This article was drafted with the assistance of artificial intelligence from verified sources and reviewed by a human editor before publication.